McKibben is in her first season as the Head Coach of the UM-Dearborn women's soccer team. McKibben was selected to lead the women's soccer program in March of 2025. 

McKibben comes to UM-Dearborn after a decorated playing career both collegiately and professionally. McKibben played collegiately at Saint Francis University (PA), where she is the school's all-time leader in points (180), goals (70) and assists (40). McKibben earned Northeast Conference Player of the Year honors four times and was inducted into the NEC Hall of Fame in 2019. While at SFU, McKibben was named a MAC Hermann Trophy Semi-Finalist, the highest individual award in collegiate soccer. Off the field, McKibben excelled in the classroom as she was named NEC Scholar-Athlete of the Year and NSCAA NCAA DI Academic All-American in 2012 and 2013. 

After SFU, McKibben would head overseas to play in the second tier of the German Bundesliga for FC Saarbrüken. In the 2017 season, she led the team in assists/game. In 2018, McKibben returned to the States, where she began her coaching career at NCAA DIII Lycoming College (PA). There, McKibben would serve as an assistant coach, where she primarily handled recruiting responsibilities and helped the Warriors to an eight-win increase from her first to her second season.